Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy: an Evidence-based Treatment for Disorders of Attachment; the Empirical Support

Ârelationships.
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy (DDP) is an6. Caregivers use attachment-facilitating
evidence-based and effective form of treatmentinterventions.
for children with trauma and disorders of7. Use of a variety of interventions, including
attachment[1]. It is an evidence-based treatment,cognitive-behavioral strategies.
meaning that there has been empirical researchDyadic Developmental Psychotherapy
published in peer-reviewed journals. Craven & Leeinterventions flow from several theoretical and
(2006) determined that DDP is a supported andempirical lines. Attachment theory (Bowlby, 1980,
acceptable treatment (category 3 in a six levelBowlby, 1988) provides the theoretical foundation
system). However, their review only includedfor Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy. Early
results from a partial preliminary presentation oftrauma disrupts the normally developing
an ongoing follow-up study, which wasattachment system by creating distorted internal
subsequently completed and published in 2006.working models of self, others, and caregivers.
This initial study compared the results of DyadicThis is one rationale for treatment in addition to
Developmental Psychotherapy with other formsthe necessity for sensitive care-giving. As
of treatment, 'usual care', 1 year after treatmentO'Connor & Zeanah (2003, p. 235) have stated,
ended. It is important to note that over 80% of"A more puzzling case is that of an adoptive
the children in the study had had over three priorfoster caregiver who is 'adequately' sensitive but
episodes of treatment, but without anythe child exhibits attachment disorder behavior; it
improvement in their symptoms and behavior.would seem unlikely that improving parental
Episodes of treatment mean a course of therapysensitive responsiveness (in already sensitive
with other mental health providers at other clinics,parent) would yield positive changes in the
consisting of at least five sessions. A secondparent-child relationship." Treatment is necessary
study extended these results out to 4 yearsto directly address the rigid and dysfunctional
after treatment ended. Based on the Craven &internalized working models that traumatized
Lee classifications (Saunders et al. 2004), inclusionchildren with attachment disorders have
of those studies would have resulted in Dyadicdeveloped.
Developmental Psychotherapy being classified asCurrent thinking and research on the neurobiology
an evidence-based category 2, 'Supported andof interpersonal behavior (Siegel, 1999, Siegel,
probably efficacious'. There have been two related2000, Siegel, 2002, Schore, 2001) is another part
empirical studies comparing treatment outcomesof the foundation on which Dyadic Developmental
of Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy with aPsychotherapy rests.
control group. This is the basis for the rating ofThe primary approach is to create a secure base
category two. The criteria are:in treatment (using techniques that fit with
* 1. The treatment has a sound theoretical basismaintaining a healing PACE (Playful, Accepting,
in generally accepted psychological principles.Curious, and Empathic) and at home using
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy is based inprincipals that provide safe structure and a healing
Attachment Theory (see texts cited belowPLACE (Playful, Loving, Acceptance, Curious, and
* 2. A substantial clinical, anecdotal literature existsEmpathic). Developing and sustaining an attuned
indicating the treatment's efficacy with at-riskrelationship within which contingent collaborative
children and foster children.communication occurs helps the child heal.
See reference list.Coercive interventions such as rib-stimulation,
* 3. The treatment is generally accepted in clinicalholding-restraining a child in anger or to provoke
practice for at risk children and foster children.an emotional response, shaming a child, using fear
As demonstrated by the large number ofto elicit compliance, and interventions based on
practitioners of Dyadic Developmentalpower/control and submission, etc., are never
Psychotherapy and it's presentation as numerousused and are inconsistent with a treatment rooted
international and national conferences over the lastin attachment theory and current knowledge
ten or fifteen years.about the neurobiology of interpersonal behavior.
* 4. There is no clinical or empirical evidence orThe usual structure of a session involves three
theoretical basis indicating - that the treatmentcomponents. First, the therapist meets with the
constitutes a substantial risk of harm to thosecaregivers in one office while the child is seated in
receiving it, compared to its likely benefits.the treatment room. During this part of
* 5. The treatment has a manual that clearlytreatment, the caregiver is instructed in
specifies the components and administrationattachment parenting methods (Becker-Weidman
characteristics of the treatment that allows for& Shell (2005) Hughes, 2006). The caregiver's
implementation.own issues that may create difficulties with
Creating Capacity for Attachment, Building thedeveloping affective attunement with their child
Bonds of Attachment, and Attachment Focusedmay also be explored and resolved. Effective
Family Therapy constitute such material.parenting methods for children with
* 6. At least two studies utilizing some form oftrauma-attachment disorders require a high
control without randomization (e.g., wait list,degree of structure and consistency, along with
untreated group, placebo group) have establishedan affective milieu that demonstrates playfulness,
the treatment's efficacy over the passage oflove, acceptance, curiosity, and empathy (PLACE).
time, efficacy over placebo, or found it to beDuring this part of the treatment, caregivers
comparable to or better than an alreadyreceive support and are given the same level of
established treatment.attuned responsiveness that we wish the child to
See ref. listexperience. Quite often caregivers feel blamed,
* 7. If multiple treatment outcome studies havedevalued, incompetent, depleted, and angry.
been conducted, the overall weight of evidenceParent-support is an important dimension of
supported the efficacy of the treatment.treatment to help caregivers be more able to
These studies support several of O'Connor &maintain an attuned connecting relationship with
Zeanah's[2] conclusions and recommendationstheir child. Second, the therapist with the
concerning treatment. They state (p. 241),caregivers meets with the child in the treatment
"treatments for children with attachmentroom. This generally takes one to one and a half
disorders should be promoted only when they arehours. Third, the therapist meets with the
evidence-based."caregivers without the child. Broadly speaking, the
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy, as withtreatment with the child uses three categories of
any specialized treatment, must be provided by ainterventions: affective attunement, cognitive
competent, well-trained, licensed professional.restructuring, and psychodramatic reenactments.
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy is aTreatment with the caregivers uses two
family-focused treatment[3].categories of interventions: first, teaching
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy is the nameeffective parenting methods and helping the
for an approach and a set of principals that havecaregivers avoid power struggles and, second,
proven to be effective in helping children withmaintaining the proper PLACE or attitude.
trauma and attachment disorders heal; that is,Treatment of the child has a significant non-verbal
develop healthy, trusting, and secure relationshipsdimension since much of the trauma took place at
with caregivers. Treatment is based on fivea pre-verbal stage and is often dissociated from
central principals.explicit memory. As a result, childhood
At the core of Reactive Attachment Disorder ismaltreatment and resultant trauma create
trauma caused by significant and substantialbarriers to successful engagement and treatment
experiences of neglect, abuse, or prolonged andof these children. Treatment interventions are
unresolved pain in the first few years of life.designed to create experiences of safety and
These experiences disrupt the normal attachmentaffective attunement so that the child is
process so that the child's capacity to form aaffectively engaged and can explore and resolve
healthy and secure attachment with a caregiver ispast trauma. This affective attunement is the
distorted or absent. The child lacks a sense trust,same process used for non-verbal communication
safety, and security. The child develops abetween a caregiver and child during attachment
negative working model of the world in which:facilitating interactions (Hughes, 2003, Siegel, 2001).
Ø Adults are experienced asThe therapist and caregivers' attunement results
inconsistent or hurtful.in co-regulation of the child's affect so that is it
Ø The world is viewed as chaotic.manageable. Cognitive restructuring interventions
Ø The child experiences no effectiveare designed to help the child develop secondary
influence on the world.mental representations of traumatic events, which
Ø The child attempts to rely only onallow the child to integrate these events and
him/her self.develop a coherent autobiographical narrative.
Ø The child feels an overwhelmingTreatment involves multiple repetitions of the
sense of shame, the child feels defective, bad,fundamental caregiver-child attachment cycle. The
unlovable, and evil.cycle begins with shared affective experiences, is
Reactive Attachment Disorder is a severefollowed by a breach in the relationship (a
developmental disorder caused by a chronicseparation or discontinuity), and ends with a
history of maltreatment during the first couple ofreattunement of affective states. Non-verbal
years of life. Reactive Attachment Disorder iscommunication, involving eye contact, tone of
frequently misdiagnosed by mental healthvoice, touch, and movement, are essential
professionals who do not have the appropriateelements to creating affective attunement.
training and experience evaluating and treatingThe treatment provided often adhered to a
such children and adults. Often, children in the childstructure with several dimensions. It is pictured in
welfare system have a variety of previousFigure 1, below. First, behavior is identified and
diagnoses. The behaviors and symptoms that areexplored. The behavior may have occurred in the
the basis for these previous diagnoses are betterimmediate interaction or have occurred at some
conceptualized as resulting from disorderedtime in the past. Using curiosity and acceptance
attachment. Oppositional Defiant Disorderthe behavior is explored. Second, using curiosity
behaviors are subsumed under Reactiveand acceptance the behavior is explore and the
Attachment Disorder. Post Traumatic Stressmeaning to the child begins to emerge. Third,
Disorder symptoms are the result of a significantempathy is used to reduce the child's sense of
history of abuse and neglect and are anothershame and increase the child's sense of being
dimension of attachment disorder. Attentionaccepted and understood. Forth, the child's
problems and even Psychotic Disorder symptomsbehavior is then normalized. In other words, once
are often seen in children with disorganizedthe meaning of the behavior and its basis in past
attachment[4].trauma is identified, it becomes understandable
Approximately 2% of the population is adopted,that the symptom is present. An example of
and between 50% and 80% of such children havesuch an interaction is the following:
attachment disorder symptoms[5]. Many of theseWow, I see how you got so angry when your
children are violent[6] and aggressive[7] and asMom asked you to pick up your toys. You
adults are at risk of developing a variety ofthought she was being mean and didn't want you
psychological problems[8] and personalityto have fun or love you. You thought she was
disorders, including antisocial personality disorder[9],going to take everything away and leave you like
narcissistic personality disorder, borderlineyour first Mom did, like when your first Mom took
personality disorder, and psychopathic personalityyour toys and then left you alone in the
disorder[10]. Neglected children are at risk of socialapartment that time. Oh, I can really understand
withdrawal, social rejection, and pervasive feelingsnow how hard that must be for you when Mom
of incompetence[11]. Children who have historiessaid to clean up. You really felt mad and scared.
of abuse and neglect are at significant risk ofThat must be so hard for you.
developing Post Traumatic Stress Disorder asÂ
adults[12]. Children who have been sexually abusedFifth, the child communicates this understanding to
are at significant risk of developing anxietythe caregiver.
disorders (2.0 times the average), majorSixth, finally, a new meaning for the behavior is
depressive disorders (3.4 times average), alcoholfound and the child's actions are integrated into a
abuse (2.5 times average), drug abuse (3.8 timescoherent autobiographical narrative by
average), and antisocial behavior (4.3 timescommunicating the new experience and meaning
average)[13] (MacMillian, 2001). The effectiveto the caregiver.
treatment of such children is a public healthPast traumas are revisited by reading documents
concern (Walker, Goodwin, & Warren, 1992).and through psychodramatic reenactments. These
Left untreated, children who have been abusedinterventions, which occur within a safe attuned
and neglected and who have an attachmentrelationship, allow the child to integrate the past
disorder become adults whose ability to developtraumas and to understand the past and present
and maintain healthy relationships is deeplyexperiences that create the feelings and thoughts
damaged. Without placement in an appropriateassociated with the child's behavioral disturbances.
permanent home and effective treatment, theThe child develops secondary representations of
condition will worsen. Many children withthese events, feelings and thoughts that result in
attachment disorders develop borderlinegreater affect regulation and a more integrated
personality disorder or anti-social personalityautobiographical narrative.
disorder as adults[14].As described by Hughes (2006, 2003), the
FIRST PRINCIPAL. Therapy must be experiential.therapy is an active, affect modulated experience
Since the roots of disorders of attachment occurthat involves acceptance, curiosity, empathy, and
pre-verbally, therapy must create experiencesplayfulness. By co-regulating the child's emerging
that are healing. Experiences, not words, are oneaffective states and developing secondary
"active ingredient" in the healing process.representations of thoughts and feelings, the
For example, one eight year old boy who hadchild's capacity to affectively engage in a trusting
Reactive Attachment Disorder, Bipolar Disorder,relationship is enhanced. The caregivers enact
and a variety of sensory-integration disordersthese same principals. If the caregivers have
wrote about his past therapy and attachmentdifficulty engaging with their child in this manner,
therapy this way (More details of this story canthen treatment of the caregiver is indicated.
be found in the book Creating Capacity forChildren who have experienced chronic
Attachment, edited by Arthur Becker-Weidman &maltreatment and resulting complex trauma are
Deborah Shell):at significant risk for a variety of other behavioral,
My first therapy was with Dr.Steve. The therapyneuropsychological, cognitive, emotional,
was FUN!!!! We ate lots of snacks. I had a bottle.interpersonal, and psychobiological disorders (Cook,
We played lots of cool games like thumbA., et. al., 2005; van der Kolk, B., 2005). Children
wrestling, pillow rides, giant walk, Superman rides,and adolescents with complex trauma require an
guess the goodies, eye blinking contests, hide andapproach to treatment that focuses on several
go seek goodies. I had to follow the rules and playdimensions of impairment (Cook, et. al., 2005).
the games just like Dr. Steve said.Chronic maltreatment and the resulting complex
Dr. Steve taught me how to play and have funtrauma cause impairment in a variety of vital
with my Mom. But I still didn't know how to love. Idomains including the following:
would still get real mad and try to hurt Mom andØ Self-regulation
break things. Inside I still thought I was a bad boy.Ø Interpersonal relating including the
I was still afraid Mom and Dad would get rid ofcapacity to trust and secure comfort
me. I had lots of tantrums at home. Sometimes IØ Attachment
would still get out of control and break things andØ Biology, resulting in somatization
try to hurt Mom. I was getting even worse whenØ Affect regulation
I got mad.Ø Increased use of defensive
Stuff Dr. Art Taught Memechanisms, such as dissociation
I learned about my feeling well. Sometimes I stuffØ Behavioral control
too many feelings like mad, scared and sad intoØ Cognitive functions, including the
my feeling well. Then the well will overflow and Iregulation of attention, interests, and other
could explode with behaviors. But I can stop thatexecutive functions.
by expressing my feelings. Then the well can'tØ Self-concept.
overflow because I let some of the feelings out.Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy addresses
I also made pictures of my heart. I was born withthese domains of impairment. Dyadic
a nice heart but then when I went into theDevelopmental Psychotherapy shares many
orphanage I got cracks in my heart. My heartimportant elements with optimal, sound social
cracked because they couldn't take good care ofcasework and clinical practice. For example,
me. I was a baby and I needed someone to holdattention to the dignity of the client, respect for
me and rock me. But they couldn't because therethe client's experiences, and starting where the
were too many babies. Then I put 16 bricksclient is, are all time-honored principles of clinical
around my heart. I was protecting my heart so itpractice and all are also central elements of
wouldn't get hurt anymore. But the bricks keptDyadic Developmental Psychotherapy
the love out too. I wouldn't let Mom's love in. I hadIn summary, therapy for traumatized children
lots of mad in my heart.who have disordered attachments must be
My hard work in therapy got rid of all the bricks.experiential, consensual, and provide an
Then Mom's love got in. The love made theenvironment of security, acceptance, safety,
cracks heal. Now I have a bright red heart withempathy, and playfulness.
no cracks.[1] Becker-Weidman, A., (2006) "Treatment for
I really liked Dr. Art now and am proud that I amChildren with Trauma-Attachment Disorders:
strong. I still don't need therapy. I still let Mom'sDyadic Developmental Psychotherapy," Child and
love into my heart!!!!!! Sometimes I send e-mail's toAdolescent Social Work Journal. Vol. 23 #2, April
Dr. Art. I tell him how good I'm doing.2006, 147-171.
I started missing Dr. Art and told Mom. Mom wasBecker-Weidman, A., (2006). "Dyadic
confused and thought I wanted more therapy. IDevelopmental Psychotherapy: A multi-year
told Mom "I don't need therapy. I just want toFollow-up," in, New Developments In Child Abuse
have lunch with Dr. Art." So I sent Dr. Art anResearch, Stanley M. Sturt, Ph.D. (Ed.) Nova
email to let him know that I wanted to have lunchScience Publishers, NY, pp. 43 -- 61.
with him. Then one day we had lunch together.Becker-Weidman, A., (2007) "Treatment For
Sometimes it's still hard. I still get mad andChildren with Reactive Attachment Disorder:
sometimes I don't express my feelings well.Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy,"
Sometimes when Mom helps me ? I can expressBecker-Weidman, A., & Hughes, D., (2008) "Dyadic
my feelings and say "I don't want to pick up myDevelopmental Psychotherapy: An evidence-based
toys. It makes me mad that I have to ? but Itreatment for children with complex trauma and
will". When I say that it doesn't make me feeldisorders of attachment," Child & Adolescent
mad anymore. It helps me to listen to Mom. ButSocial Work, 13, pp.329-337.
sometimes when I get mad I pout and stompCraven, P. & Lee, R. (2006) Therapeutic
my feet and run to my room if I forget tointerventions for foster children: a systematic
express my feelings. But now I let Mom help meresearch synthesis. Research on Social Work
so that I can talk about my feelings and do whatPractice, 16, 287-304.
she says[2] O'Connor, T., & Zeanah, C., (2003) Attachment
It's been a really longtime since I tried to hurtDisorders: Assessment strategies and treatment
Mom or break things when I'm mad. I feel goodapproaches. Attachment & Human Development,
about love now. I know that my Mom and Dad5, 223-245.
love me. I know that I love Mom and Dad. I don't[3] Hughes, D., (2008) Attachment-focused Family
feel like I'm a bad boy anymore.Therapy. NY: Norton.
Effective therapy uses experiences to help a child[4] Lyons-Ruth, K., & Jacobvitz, D., Attachment
experience safety, security, acceptance,disorganization: unresolved loss, relational violence
empathy, and emotional attunement within theand lapses in behavioral and attentional strategies.
family. A number of techniques and methods areIn Cassidy, J. & Shaver, P., (Eds.) Handbook of
used including psychodrama, interventionsAttachment. pp 520-554, NY: Guilford Press, 1999.
congruent with Theraplay, and other exercises.Solomon, J. & George, C. (Eds.). Attachment
SECOND PRINCIPAL. Therapy must beDisorganization. NY: Guilford Press, 1999.
family-focused. Therapy helps the child addressMain, M. & Hesse, E. Parents' Unresolved
the underlying trauma in a supportive, safe,Traumatic Experiences are related to infant
secure environment in "titrated" and manageabledisorganized attachment status. In Greenberg,
doses so that what the parents have to offerM.T., Ciccehetti, D., & Cummings, E.M. (Eds.)
can get in and heal the child. It is the parents'Attachment in the Preschool Years: Theory,
capacity to create a safe and nurturing home thatResearch, and Intervention, pp.161-182, Chicago:
provides a healing environment. Being able to haveUniversity of Chicago Press, 1990.
empathy for the child, accept the child, love theCarlson, E.A. (1988). A prospective longitudinal
child, be curious about the child, and be playful arestudy of disorganized/disoriented attachment. Child
all part of the "attitude[15]" that heals. Parents areDevelopment 69, 1107-1128.
actively involved in treatment.[5] Carlson, V., Cicchetti, D., Barnett, D., &
THIRD PRINCIPAL. The trauma must be directlyBraunwald, K. (1995). Finding order in
addressed. Therapy helps healing by providing thedisorganization: Lessons from research on
safety and security so that the child canmaltreated infants' attachments to their
re-experience the painful and shameful emotionscaregivers. In D. Cicchetti & V. Carlson (Eds), Child
that surround the child's trauma. Revisiting theMaltreatment: Theory and research on the causes
trauma is essential if the child is to begin to reviseand consequences of child abuse and neglect (pp.
the child's personal narrative and world-view. It is135-157). NY: Cambridge University Press.
by revisiting the trauma and sharing the anger andCicchetti, D., Cummings, E.M., Greenberg, M.T., &
shame with an accepting, empathetic person thatMarvin, R.S. (1990). An organizational perspective
the child can integrate the trauma into a coherenton attachment beyond infancy. In M. Greenberg,
self.D. Cicchetti, & M. Cummings (Eds), Attachment in
FOURTH PRINCIPAL. A comprehensive milieu ofthe Preschool Years (pp. 3-50). Chicago: University
safety and security must be created.of Chicago Press.
Traumatized children are often hyper-vigilant,[6] Robins, L.N. (1978) Longitudinal studies: Sturdy
insecure, and deeply distrusting. A consistentchildhood predictors of adult antisocial behavior.
environment that is safe and secure is essentialPsychological Medicine,. 8, 611-622.
to creating the experiences necessary for the[7] Prino, C.T. & Peyrot, M. (1994) The effect of
child to heal. This milieu must be present at homechild physical abuse and neglect on aggressive
and in therapy. Good communication andwithdrawn, and prosocial behavior. Child Abuse and
coordination among home, school, and therapy isNeglect, 18, 871-884.
another important element of effective[8] Schreiber, R. & Lyddon, W. J. (1998) Parental
treatment. "Compression-wraps," invasive andbonding and Current Psychological Functioning
intrusive stimulation designed to evoke rage,Among Childhood Sexual Abuse Survivors. Journal
"re-birthing," and other provocative techniques areof Counseling Psychology, 45, 358-362.
not part of Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy.Â
These intrusive and invasive techniques are not[9] Finzi, R., Cohen, O., Sapir, Y., & Weizman, A.
therapy, not therapeutic, and have no place in a(2000). Attachment Styles in Maltreated Children:
reputable treatment program.A Comparative Study. Child Development and
Fifth Principal. Therapy is consensual and notHuman Development, 31, 113-128.
coercive. At our center we are very clear that[10] Dozier, M., Stovall, K.C., & Albus, K. (1999)
physical restraint is not treatment and is not usedAttachment and Psychopathology in Adulthood. In
in treatment in any manner. Treatment isJ. Cassidy & P. Shaver (Eds.). Handbook of
provided in a manner consisted with theAttachment (pp. 497-519). NY: Guilford Press.
Association for the treatment and Training of[11] Finzi, R., Cohen, O., Sapir, Y., & Weizman, A.
Children's White Paper on Coercion in treatment.(2000). Attachment Styles in Maltreated Children:
DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF TREATMENTA Comparative Study. Child Development and
Dyadic Developmental Psychotherapy is aHuman Development, 31, 113-128.
treatment developed by Daniel Hughes, Ph.D.,Â
(Hughes, 2008, Hughes, 2006, Hughes, 2003,). Its[12] Allan, J. (2001). Traumatic Relationships and
basic principals are described by Hughes andSerious Mental Disorders. NY: John Wiley.
summarized as follows:Andrews, B., Varewin, C.R., Rose, S., & Kirk
1. A focus on both the caregivers and therapists(2000). Predicting PTSD symptoms in Victims of
own attachment strategies. Previous researchViolent Crime. Journal of Abnormal Psychology,
(Dozier, 2001, Tyrell 1999) has shown the109, 69-73.
importance of the caregivers and therapists stateÂ
of mind for the success of interventions.[13] MacMillian, H.L. (2001). Childhood Abuse and
2. Therapist and caregiver are attuned to theLifetime Psychopathology in a Community Sample.
child's subjective experience and reflect this backAmerican Journal of Psychiatry, 158, 1878-1883.
to the child. In the process of maintaining anÂ
intersubjective attuned connection with the child,[14] Allan, J. Traumatic Relationships and Serious
the therapist and caregiver help the child regulateMental Disorders, NY: Wiley, 2001.
affect and construct a coherent autobiographicalAndrews, B., Varewin, C.R., Rose, S. & Kirk.
narrative.Predicting PTSD symptoms in Victims of Violent
3. Sharing of subjective experiences.Crime. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, vol. 109,
4. Use of PACE and PLACE are essential to69-73, 2000.
healing.Â
5. Directly address the inevitable misattunements[15] Hughes, D., (2007) Building the Bonds of
and conflicts that arise in interpersonalAttachment, 2nd. Edition, NY: Guilford Press.