How Much Inattention is Abnormal?

A recent article in the American Academy ofeffectively interfere with a student's lack of
Pediatrics website addressed the normal range oflearning readiness in the classroom. It is alarming
attention in children. This article simply stated thatfor me to observe the frequency of ADHD
everyone will show difficulty with attention inreferrals for students who are more accurately
some circumstances at one time or another.impaired by learning weaknesses, poor academic
Another way of stating this fact would be that itmotivation, weak work-study habits, behavior
is normal for children and adults alike to struggleproblems, and/or emotional difficulties.
at times with attention and focus. The following isA major weakness of the DSM-IV description of
an excerpt from this article:ADHD symptoms is the absence of objective
ADHD - Common Behaviors and Symptomscriteria describing intensity, frequency, and
At one time or another, almost all children seemduration of symptoms necessary to support this
to show symptoms of Attention-Deficitdiagnosis. Any one reading the ADHD symptom
Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD). It is normal for alllist can easily "see themselves" reflected in the
children to show some of these symptoms fromdescription of impairment. This uncomfortable
time to time. Your child may be reacting to stressrealization is an all too frequent experience
at school or home. She may be bored or goingprimarily due to the lack of specific criteria
through a difficult stage of life. It does not meanoffered to measure the degree of inattention.
she has ADHD.Until more specific symptom criteria are offered,
True ADHD symptoms appear on a regular basisthe diagnosis of ADHD will remain the product of
and can interfere with learning. That is why aclinical judgment.
teacher sometimes is the first to noticePerhaps of more importance is the necessary
inattention, hyperactivity and/or impulsivity andrecognition of variable attention recognized in
bring these symptoms to the parents' attention.every child including the student in the classroom.
Or perhaps questions from your pediatrician raisedIn addition to the possibility of alternative
the issue. At routine visits, pediatricians often askconditions which may be disrupting a student's
questions such as the following:o How is your childattention in the classroom, there is also the
doing in school?o Are there any problems withpossibility that limited attention can be best
learning that you or your child's teachers haveunderstood as simply a product of developmental
seen?o Is your child happy in school?o Is yourimmaturity. When considering younger students in
child having problems completing class work orthe classroom, we must realize that not all
homework?o Are you concerned with anychildren develop at the same rate. Developmental
behavior problems in school, at home or whendifferences can be observed as substantial
your child is playing with friends?differences in students' readiness and availability
Your answers to these questions may lead tofor learning. Failure to recognize the impact of
further evaluation for ADHD.developmental delay could result in a child being
This article wisely addresses some of the factorsinaccurately and unjustifiably labeled and
which may easily interfere with a child's ability tomedicated. It is important for parents and
learn in the classroom. Although classroomteachers to remember that students develop and
teachers often recognize a student's off-tasklearn at an individual pace and time that may not
behavior in the classroom, they may prematurelyalways coincide with the performance
assume that task inattention is an indication ofexpectations in the classroom.
ADHD. It is a fact that inattention is a criticalThis realization highlights the importance of
impairment recognized in all ADHD children.evaluating the whole child in the child's individual
However, one must recognize that the symptomenvironment. Caution should be recognized when
of inattention is a product of a variety ofobserving the mere symptom of inattention.
alternative diagnostic conditions. As stated in theUnfortunately, too many practitioners are quick to
American Academy of Pediatrics article, factorssuggest ADHD in response to a child described
as basic as stress, boredom, or motivation can bewith inattention. The DSM-IV symptoms of ADHD
reasonable explanations of a student's off-taskmerely offer a basic framework for the
behavior. In addition, there are numerous othercomprehensive evaluation that still needs to be
routine life events and daily experiences that cancompleted by a child professional.